critical thinking elements of reasoning

Our Team of Presenters
Fellows of the Foundation
Dr. Richard Paul
Dr. Linda Elder
Dr. Gerald Nosich
Contact Us - Office Information
Permission to Use Our Work
Create a CriticalThinking.Org Account
Contributions to the Foundation for Critical Thinking
Testimonials
Center for Critical Thinking
The National Council for Excellence in Critical Thinking
International Center for the Assessment of Higher Order Thinking
Library of Critical Thinking Resources
Professional Development
Inservice Information Request Form
Spring 2025 Certification Online Course
The State of Critical Thinking Today
Higher Education
K-12 Instruction
Customized Webinars and Online Courses for Faculty
Business & Professional Groups
The Center for Critical Thinking Community Online
Certification in the Paul-Elder Approach to Critical Thinking
Professional Development Model - College and University
Professional Development Model for K-12
Workshop Descriptions
Online Courses in Critical Thinking
Critical Thinking Training for Law Enforcement
Consulting for Leaders and Key Personnel at Your Organization
Critical Thinking Therapy
Conferences & Events
Upcoming Learning Opportunities
45th Annual International Conference on Critical Thinking
Call for Proposals
Travel & Lodging
Daily Schedule
Testimonials from Past Conferences
Presuppositions of the Conference
Conference Archives
44th Annual International Conference on Critical Thinking
Focal Session Descriptions
Guest Presentation Program
Presuppositions of the 44th Annual International Conference on Critical Thinking
Recommended Reading
43rd Annual International Conference on Critical Thinking
Register as an Ambassador
Testimonials from Past Attendees
Thank You to Our Donors
42nd Annual International Conference on Critical Thinking
Overview of Sessions (Flyer)
Presuppositions of the Annual International Conference
41st Annual International Conference on Critical Thinking
Recommended Publications
Dedication to Our Donors
40th Annual International Conference on Critical Thinking
Session Descriptions
Testimonials from Prior Conferences
International Critical Thinking Manifesto
Scholarships Available
39th Annual International Conference on Critical Thinking
Travel and Lodging Info
FAQ & General Announcements
Focal and Plenary Session Descriptions
Program and Proceedings of the 39th Annual International Conference on Critical Thinking
The Venue: KU Leuven
Call for Critical Thinking Ambassadors
Conference Background Information
38th Annual International Conference on Critical Thinking
Call for Ambassadors for Critical Thinking
Conference Focal Session Descriptions
Conference Concurrent Session Descriptions
Conference Roundtable Discussions
Conference Announcements and FAQ
Conference Program and Proceedings
Conference Daily Schedule
Conference Hotel Information
Conference Academic Credit
Conference Presuppositions
What Participants Have Said About the Conference
37th Annual International Conference on Critical Thinking
Registration & Fees
FAQ and Announcements
Conference Presenters
37th Conference Flyer
Program and Proceedings of the 37th Conference
36th International Conference
Conference Sessions
Conference Flyer
Program and Proceedings
Academic Credit
35th International Conference
Conference Session Descriptions
Available Online Sessions
Bertrand Russell Distinguished Scholar - Daniel Ellsberg
35th International Conference Program
Concurrent Sessions
Posthumous Bertrand Russell Scholar
Hotel Information
Conference FAQs
Visiting UC Berkeley
34th INTERNATIONAL CONFERENCE
Bertrand Russell Distinguished Scholar - Ralph Nader
Conference Concurrent Presenters
Conference Program
Conference Theme
Roundtable Discussions
Flyer for Bulletin Boards
33rd INTERNATIONAL CONFERENCE
33rd International Conference Program
33rd International Conference Sessions
33rd International Conference Presenters
The Bertrand Russell Distinguished Scholars Critical Thinking Conversations
33rd International Conference - Fees & Registration
33rd International Conference Concurrent Presenters
33rd International Conference - Hotel Information
33rd International Conference Flyer
32nd INTERNATIONAL CONFERENCE
32nd Annual Conference Sessions
32nd Annual Conference Presenter Information
32nd Conference Program
The Bertrand Russell Distinguished Scholars Critical Thinking Lecture Series
32nd Annual Conference Concurrent Presenters
32nd Annual Conference Academic Credit
31st INTERNATIONAL CONFERENCE
31st Conference Sessions
Comments about previous conferences
Conference Hotel (2011)
31st Concurrent Presenters
Registration Fees
31st International Conference
30th INTERNATIONAL CONFERENCE ON CRITICAL THINKING
30th International Conference Theme
30th Conference Sessions
PreConference Sessions
30th Concurrent Presenters
30th Conference Presuppositions
Hilton Garden Inn
29th International Conference
29th Conference Theme
29th Conference Sessions
29th Preconference Sessions
29th Conference Concurrent Sessions
2008 International Conference on Critical Thinking
2008 Preconference Sessions (28th Intl. Conference)
2007 Conference on Critical Thinking (Main Page)
2007 Conference Theme and sessions
2007 Pre-Conference Workshops
2006 Annual International Conference (archived)
2006 International Conference Theme
2005 International Conference (archived)
Prior Conference Programs (Pre 2000)
Workshop Archives
Spring 2022 Online Workshops
2021 Online Workshops for Winter & Spring
2019 Seminar for Military and Intelligence Trainers and Instructors
Transportation, Lodging, and Recreation
Seminar Flyer
2013 Spring Workshops
Our Presenters
2013 Spring Workshops - Hotel Information
2013 Spring Workshops Flyer
2013 Spring Workshops - Schedule
Spring Workshop 2012
2012 Spring Workshop Strands
2012 Spring Workshop Flier
2011 Spring Workshop
Spring 2010 Workshop Strands
2009 Spring Workshops on Critical Thinking
2008 SPRING Workshops and Seminars on Critical Thinking
2008 Ethical Reasoning Workshop
2008 - On Richard Paul's Teaching Design
2008 Engineering Reasoning Workshop
2008 Academia sobre Formulando Preguntas Esenciales
Academy Archives
2024 Fall Academy on Critical Thinking
Transportation, Lodging, and Social Functions
Critical Thinking Therapy Release & Book Signing
Academy Presuppositions
October 2019 Critical Thinking Academy for Educators and Administrators
Transportation, Lodging, and Leisure
Advanced Seminar: Oxford Tutorial
Recreational Group Activities
Limited Scholarships Available
September 2019 Critical Thinking Educators and Administrators Academy
2019 Critical Thinking Training for Trainers and Advanced Academy
Academy Flyer
Seattle, WA 2017 Spring Academy
San Diego, CA 2017 Spring Academy
2016 Spring Academy -- Washington D.C.
2016 Spring Academy -- Houston, TX
The 2nd International Academy on Critical Thinking (Oxford 2008)
2007 National Academy on Critical Thinking Testing and Assessment
2006 Cambridge Academy (archived)
2006 Cambridge Academy Theme
2006 Cambridge Academy Sessions
Accommodations at St. John's College
Fellows Academy Archives
2017 Fall International Fellows Academy
4th International Fellows Academy - 2016
3rd International Fellows Academy
2nd International Fellows Academy
1st International Fellows Academy
Assessment & Testing
A Model for the National Assessment of Higher Order Thinking
International Critical Thinking Essay Test
Online Critical Thinking Basic Concepts Test
Online Critical Thinking Basic Concepts Sample Test
Consequential Validity: Using Assessment to Drive Instruction
News & Announcements
Newest Pages Added to CriticalThinking.Org
Online Learning
Critical Thinking Online Courses
Critical Thinking Blog
2019 Blog Entries
2020 Blog Entries
2021 Blog Entries
2022 Blog Entries
2023 Blog Entries
Online Courses for Your Students
2023 Webinar Archives
2022 Webinar Archives
2021 Webinar Archive
2020 Webinar Archive
Guided Study Groups
Critical Thinking Channel on YouTube
CT800: Fall 2024

Translate this page from English...

*Machine translated pages not guaranteed for accuracy. Click Here for our professional translations.

Critical Thinking: Where to Begin

For College and University Faculty
For College and University Students
For High School Teachers
For Jr. High School Teachers
For Elementary Teachers (Grades 4-6)
For Elementary Teachers (Kindergarten - 3rd Grade)
For Science and Engineering Instruction
For Business and Professional Development
For Nursing and Health Care
For Home Schooling and Home Study

If you are new to critical thinking or wish to deepen your conception of it, we recommend you review the content below and bookmark this page for future reference.

Our Conception of Critical Thinking...

"Critical thinking is the intellectually disciplined process of actively and skillfully conceptualizing, applying, analyzing, synthesizing, and/or evaluating information gathered from, or generated by, observation, experience, reflection, reasoning, or communication, as a guide to belief and action. In its exemplary form, it is based on universal intellectual values that transcend subject matter divisions: clarity, accuracy, precision, consistency, relevance, sound evidence, good reasons, depth, breadth, and fairness..."

"Critical thinking is self-guided, self-disciplined thinking which attempts to reason at the highest level of quality in a fairminded way. People who think critically attempt, with consistent and conscious effort, to live rationally, reasonably, and empathically. They are keenly aware of the inherently flawed nature of human thinking when left unchecked. They strive to diminish the power of their egocentric and sociocentric tendencies. They use the intellectual tools that critical thinking offers – concepts and principles that enable them to analyze, assess, and improve thinking. They work diligently to develop the intellectual virtues of intellectual integrity, intellectual humility, intellectual civility, intellectual empathy, intellectual sense of justice and confidence in reason. They realize that no matter how skilled they are as thinkers, they can always improve their reasoning abilities and they will at times fall prey to mistakes in reasoning, human irrationality, prejudices, biases, distortions, uncritically accepted social rules and taboos, self-interest, and vested interest.

They strive to improve the world in whatever ways they can and contribute to a more rational, civilized society. At the same time, they recognize the complexities often inherent in doing so. They strive never to think simplistically about complicated issues and always to consider the rights and needs of relevant others. They recognize the complexities in developing as thinkers, and commit themselves to life-long practice toward self-improvement. They embody the Socratic principle: The unexamined life is not worth living , because they realize that many unexamined lives together result in an uncritical, unjust, dangerous world."

Why Critical Thinking?

The Problem:

Everyone thinks; it is our nature to do so. But much of our thinking, left to itself, is biased, distorted, partial, uninformed, or down-right prejudiced. Yet the quality of our lives and that of what we produce, make, or build depends precisely on the quality of our thought. Shoddy thinking is costly, both in money and in quality of life. Excellence in thought, however, must be systematically cultivated.

A Brief Definition:

Critical thinking is the art of analyzing and evaluating thinking with a view to improving it. The Result:

A well-cultivated critical thinker:

raises vital questions and problems, formulating them clearly and precisely;
gathers and assesses relevant information, using abstract ideas to interpret it effectively;
comes to well-reasoned conclusions and solutions, testing them against relevant criteria and standards;
thinks openmindedly within alternative systems of thought, recognizing and assessing, as need be, their assumptions, implications, and practical consequences; and
communicates effectively with others in figuring out solutions to complex problems.

Critical thinking is, in short, self-directed, self-disciplined, self-monitored, and self-corrective thinking. It requires rigorous standards of excellence and mindful command of their use. It entails effective communication and problem-solving abilities, and a commitment to overcoming our native egocentrism and sociocentrism. Read more about our concept of critical thinking .

The Essential Dimensions of Critical Thinking

Our conception of critical thinking is based on the substantive approach developed by Dr. Richard Paul and his colleagues at the Center and Foundation for Critical Thinking over multiple decades. It is relevant to every subject, discipline, and profession, and to reasoning through the problems of everyday life. It entails five essential dimensions of critical thinking:

At the left is an overview of the first three dimensions. In sum, the elements or structures of thought enable us to "take our thinking apart" and analyze it. The intellectual standards are used to assess and evaluate the elements. The intellectual traits are dispositions of mind embodied by the fairminded critical thinker. To cultivate the mind, we need command of these essential dimensions, and we need to consistently apply them as we think through the many problems and issues in our lives.

The Elements of Reasoning and Intellectual Standards

To learn more about the elements of thought and how to apply the intellectual standards, check out our interactive model. Simply click on the link below, scroll to the bottom of the page, and explore the model with your mouse.

Why the Analysis of Thinking Is Important If you want to think well, you must understand at least the rudiments of thought, the most basic structures out of which all thinking is made. You must learn how to take thinking apart. Analyzing the Logic of a Subject When we understand the elements of reasoning, we realize that all subjects, all disciplines, have a fundamental logic defined by the structures of thought embedded within them. Therefore, to lay bare a subject’s most fundamental logic, we should begin with these questions:

Going Deeper...

The Critical Thinking Bookstore

Our online bookstore houses numerous books and teacher's manuals , Thinker's Guides , videos , and other educational materials .

Learn From Our Fellows and Scholars

Watch our Event Calendar , which provides an overview of all upcoming conferences and academies hosted by the Foundation for Critical Thinking. Clicking an entry on the Event Calendar will bring up that event's details, and the option to register. For those interested in online learning, the Foundation offers accredited online courses in critical thinking for both educators and the general public, as well as an online test for evaluating basic comprehension of critical thinking concepts . We are in the process of developing more online learning tools and tests to offer the community.

Utilizing this Website

This website contains large amounts research and an online library of articles , both of which are freely available to the public. We also invite you to become a member of the Critical Thinking Community , where you will gain access to more tools and materials. If you cannot locate a resource on a specific topic or concept, try searching for it using our Search Tool . The Search Tool is at the upper-right of every page on the website.

Designorate

Design thinking, innovation, user experience and healthcare design

How to Apply Paul-Elder Critical Thinking Framework

The critical thinking framework provides an efficient method for designers, design students, and researchers to evaluate arguments and ideas through rational reasoning. As a result, we eliminate biases, distractions, and similar factors that negatively affect our decisions and judgments. We can use critical thinking to escape our current mindsets to reach innovative outcomes.

The critical thinking framework is based on three main stages; observe the problem to build rational knowledge, ask questions to analyze and evaluate data, and find answers to the questions that can be formulated into a solution. These stages are translated into six steps ( 6 Steps for Effective Critical Thinking ):

Knowledge – Define the main topic that needs to be covered
Comprehension – Understand the issue through researching the topic
Application – Analyze the data and link between the collected data
Analysis – Solve the problem, or the issue investigated
Synthesis – Turn the solution into an implementable action plan
Evaluate – test and evaluate the solution

Based on the above, the essential part of the critical thinking framework represents building clear, coherent reasoning for the problem, which will help ensure that the topic is addressed in the critical thinking stages.

Guide for Critical Thinking for Designers
6 Steps for Effective Critical Thinking
The Six Hats of Critical Thinking and How to Use Them

The Paul-Elder Critical Thinking Framework

In 2001, Paul and Elder introduced the critical thinking framework that helps students to master their thinking dimensions through identifying the thinking parts and evaluating the usage of these parts. The framework aims to improve our reasoning by identifying its different elements through three main elements; elements of reasoning, intellectual standards, and intellectual traits.

Elements of Reasoning

Whenever we have a topic or argument to discuss, we tend to use a number of thinking models to understand the topic at hand (i.e. Using Inductive Reasoning in User Experience Research ). These parts are known as the elements of thought or reasoning. Our minds may use these parts over the course to think about the idea:

Purpose – This part of our thinking includes defining the topic’s goal or objective. For example, the goal may involve solving a problem or achieving a target. Attempt – This part includes the attempts that previously addressed the topic or attempts to solve a problem. Assumption – Before solving a problem, we don’t have much information about the topic. Therefore, we build assumptions to act as the base of our research about the issue. We usually start with inductive inferences. Then, we use the research data to validate these assumptions. For example, we assume that all apples are red and start to research the different types of trees to know that some apples are green and some are red. The point of View includes the personal perspective we take while thinking about the topic. For instance, we can think about the product from the consumer perspective rather than the business perspective. Data, Information, and Evidence – Here, we cover the data and information related to the topic. Also, here we have all the supportive evidence. Concepts and Ideas – We have all the principles, models, and theories related to the topic. For example, this part may include all the views associated with applying a specific solution. Inferences and Interpretations – The last part includes the concluded solutions based on the previous factors. The conclusion may consist of the suggested solution to a specific problem. Implications and Consequences – All the reasons must lead to consequences resulting from implementing the results of the reasoning process.

Intellectual Standards

The above reasoning parts require a good quality benchmark to achieve its goals and ensure the accuracy of results. The intellectual standards are nine factors that can evaluate the equality of the reason parts mentioned above. These standards include clarity, accuracy, precision, relevance, depth, breadth, logic, significance, and fairness. Based on these standards, we can ask ourselves questions to evaluate the parts above. The below table provides examples of the questions that we can ask to assess the equality of our ideas.

The below two videos include Dr. Richard Paul’s lectures about the standards of thought and critical thinking.

Intellectual Traits

As a result of the application for the above reasoning parts and validating them using intellectual standards, The below characteristics are expected to evolve, known as the intellectual traits:

Intellectual Humility

This trait develops one’s ability to perceive the known limitation and the circumstances that may cause biases and self-deceptively. It depends on recognizing that one claims what one’s knows.

Intellectual Courage

Courage represents developing a consciousness to address ideas fairly regardless of its point of View or our negative emotions about it. Also, it helps us develop our ability to evaluate ideas regardless of our presumptions and perceptions about them.

Intellectual Empathy

Empathy is related to developing the ability to put ourselves in others’ shoes to understand them. Also, it forms how we can see the parts of reasoning of the others, such as the viewpoints, assumptions, and ideas.

Intellectual Integrity

This part is related to developing the ability to integrate with other intellectual reasoning and avoid the confusion of our reasoning. Unlike empathy, integrity focuses on the ability to others’ reasoning for the topic and integrate with it.

Intellectual Perseverance

Perseverance develops the need to have a proper insight about the situation regardless of the barriers faced against it, such as difficulties, frustration, and obstacles. This helps us to build rational reasoning despite what is standing against it.

Confidence in Reason

By applying the reasoning parts and encouraging people to develop their reasons, they build confidence in their reason and rational thinking.

Fair-mindedness

This trait develops the ability to start with a fair look at all the reasoning and traits of all the viewpoints, putting aside one’s feelings, raises, and interests.

The critical thinking framework can help us address topics and problems more rationally, contributing to building a clear understanding of topics. This can be achieved through having clear reasoning about the addressed topics. The Paul-Eder Critical Thinking Framework was introduced in 2001 to improve the critical thinking process by understanding the parts of the reasons and providing a method to evaluate it. You can learn more about the framework through the Miniature Guide to Critical Thinking published by the Foundation of Critical Thinking.

Understanding the thinking elements and how to evaluate our reasoning related to each part, we can improve our thoughts through time. Additionally, seven main advantages (intellectual traits) can be achieved.

Paul-Elder’s critical thinking framework identifies the thinking parts through eight elements of reasoning (purpose, attempt, assumption, point of view, data, concepts and ideas, and inference and interpretation). Nine benchmarks are used to evaluate the application of the above elements (clarity, accuracy, precision, relevance, depth, breadth, logic, significance and fairness).

What are the critical thinking framework elements?

Define the main topic that needs to be covered

Understand the issue through researching the topic

Analyze the data and link between the collected data

Solve the problem, or the issue investigated

Turn the solution into an implementable action plan

Test and evaluate the solution

The application of the Paul-Elder Critical Thinking Framework is based on identifying eight elements of reasoning: Purpose, Attempt, Assumption, Point of View, Data and Evidence, Concepts and Ideas, Inferences and Interpretations and Implications and Consequences.

Wait, Join my Newsletters!

As always, I try to come to you with design ideas, tips, and tools for design and creative thinking. Subscribe to my newsletters to receive new updated design tools and tips!

Dr Rafiq Elmansy

As an academic and author, I've had the privilege of shaping the design landscape. I teach design at the University of Leeds and am the Programme Leader for the MA Design, focusing on design thinking, design for health, and behavioural design. I've developed and taught several innovative programmes at Wrexham Glyndwr University, Northumbria University, and The American University in Cairo. I'm also a published book author and the proud founder of Designorate.com, a platform that has been instrumental in fostering design innovation. My expertise in design has been recognised by prestigious organizations. I'm a fellow of the Higher Education Academy (HEA), the Design Research Society (FDRS), and an Adobe Education Leader. Over the course of 20 years, I've had the privilege of working with esteemed clients such as the UN, World Bank, Adobe, and Schneider, contributing to their design strategies. For more than 12 years, I collaborated closely with the Adobe team, playing a key role in the development of many Adobe applications.